# Phase 21: Item & Catalog Detail Pages - Discussion Log

> **Audit trail only.** Do not use as input to planning, research, or execution agents.

**Date:** 2026-04-06
**Phase:** 21-item-catalog-detail-pages
**Areas discussed:** Detail page layout, Edit mode UX, Candidate navigation, Panel removal, Route structure
**Mode:** Auto (--auto) — decisions from earlier conversation applied

---

## Key Decisions from Conversation

| Decision | Source | Notes |
|----------|--------|-------|
| Private detail at `/items/:id` | User conversation | Full page, not side panel |
| Public detail at `/global-items/:id` | User conversation | With "Add to Collection" button |
| No visual distinction reference vs standalone | User conversation | Same layout, fields may be empty |
| Edit via toggle button, not inline by default | User conversation | Clean aesthetic priority |
| Candidates get detail pages too | User conversation | Same pattern as items |
| Remove all slide-out panels | User conversation | Both item and candidate panels |

## Claude's Discretion

- Detail page layout proportions
- Add Candidate pattern on thread page
- Edit mode animation
- Mobile adaptations
- "Linked to catalog" indicator style

## Deferred Ideas

- Reviews/ratings, community stats, setup appearances, similar items, image gallery
