test(29): re-test UAT - 4 passed, 2 issues (crop conflicts)

.planning/phases/29-image-presentation/29-UAT.md

@@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ status: complete
 phase: 29-image-presentation
 source: [29-01-SUMMARY.md, 29-02-SUMMARY.md, 29-03-SUMMARY.md, 29-04-SUMMARY.md]
 started: 2026-04-12T19:10:00Z
-updated: 2026-04-12T19:20:00Z
+updated: 2026-04-13T12:00:00Z
 ---
 
 ## Current Test
@@ -14,102 +14,67 @@ updated: 2026-04-12T19:20:00Z
 
 ### 1. Images use fit-within instead of crop
 expected: Browse any page with item/catalog cards. Images should fit inside the frame without cropping — full image visible, no parts cut off.
-result: issue
+result: pass
-reported: "Fit-within works on detail pages but collection view cards don't render images at all."
-severity: major
 
 ### 2. Dominant color background fill
 expected: Where an image doesn't fill the entire frame, the empty space is filled with a color extracted from the image (not white or gray).
-result: issue
+result: pass
-reported: "Background is just plain gray. Even newly uploaded images don't get a dominant color — extraction not working or color not passed to frontend."
-severity: major
 
 ### 3. Crop editor on item detail
-expected: Open an item that has an image. You should see an "Adjust framing" button. Clicking it opens a crop editor with zoom slider.
+expected: Open an item that has an image. In edit mode, you should see a crop icon button next to the trash icon, positioned as an overlay on the image. Clicking it opens a crop editor with zoom slider.
 result: issue
-reported: "'Adjust framing' text doesn't feel like an action. Should be an icon button, only visible in edit mode, positioned below the X icon. X icon should be a trash icon to symbolize removal."
+reported: "the button is there the framing just doesn't work i think the framing and the fit within might be fighting over it"
-severity: minor
+severity: major
 
 ### 4. Crop editor on image upload
-expected: Upload a new image to an item. After the upload completes, a crop editor should appear.
+expected: Upload a new image to an item. After the upload completes, a crop editor should appear automatically.
 result: issue
-reported: "Crop editor doesn't open when adding an image to an existing item. Can only be edited afterward."
+reported: "crop editor opens on upload correctly, but after cropping the cropped image isn't shown in the edit state always — after clicking save it is shown correctly"
-severity: major
+severity: minor
 
 ### 5. Crop settings persist
 expected: Adjust the crop on an item image, save it. Navigate away and come back — image displays with saved crop settings.
-result: issue
+result: pass
-reported: "Framing adjustment doesn't save. No error message, no console log — silently fails."
-severity: blocker
 
 ### 6. Consistency across surfaces
 expected: All image surfaces use the same fit-within + dominant color treatment.
 result: pass
-reported: "Consistent across all surfaces where images render (detail pages). Collection cards don't render images (see test 1)."
 
 ## Summary
 
 total: 6
-passed: 2
+passed: 4
-issues: 4
+issues: 2
 pending: 0
 skipped: 0
+blocked: 0
 
 ## Gaps
 
-- truth: "Collection view cards should render images using GearImage component"
+- truth: "Crop framing should visibly adjust the image within the fit-within frame"
   status: failed
-  reason: "User reported: images not rendering on collection view cards, only on detail pages"
+  reason: "User reported: framing doesn't work — fit-within and crop may be fighting over each other"
   severity: major
-  test: 1
-  artifacts:
-    - src/client/components/ItemCard.tsx
-    - src/client/components/GearImage.tsx
-  missing:
-    - GearImage integration in collection card view
-
-- truth: "Dominant color should be extracted on upload and used as background fill"
-  status: failed
-  reason: "User reported: background is plain gray even for newly uploaded images — extraction not working or color not reaching frontend"
-  severity: major
-  test: 2
-  artifacts:
-    - src/server/services/image.service.ts
-    - src/client/components/GearImage.tsx
-  missing:
-    - Debug extractDominantColor pipeline
-    - Verify color is returned from upload API and stored in DB
-    - Verify frontend reads and applies dominantColor
-
-- truth: "Crop editor should be an icon button visible only in edit mode, with trash icon for image removal"
-  status: failed
-  reason: "User reported: 'Adjust framing' text doesn't feel like an action. Should be icon, edit-mode only. X should be trash icon."
-  severity: minor
   test: 3
   artifacts:
-    - src/client/routes/items/$itemId.tsx
+    - path: "src/client/components/GearImage.tsx"
-    - src/client/components/ImageCropEditor.tsx
+      issue: "fit-within object-contain may override crop transform"
+    - path: "src/client/components/ImageCropEditor.tsx"
+      issue: "crop output not applied as CSS transform on GearImage"
   missing:
-    - Redesign crop trigger as icon button in edit mode
+    - Reconcile crop positioning with fit-within rendering — crop should adjust focal point within the contain frame
-    - Replace X with trash icon for image removal
+  root_cause: ""
+  debug_session: ""
 
-- truth: "Crop editor should open automatically when uploading a new image"
+- truth: "Cropped image preview should update in edit state immediately after cropping"
   status: failed
-  reason: "User reported: crop editor doesn't open when adding image to existing item"
+  reason: "User reported: cropped image not shown in edit state after cropping, but renders correctly after save"
-  severity: major
+  severity: minor
   test: 4
   artifacts:
-    - src/client/components/ImageUpload.tsx
+    - path: "src/client/routes/items/$itemId.tsx"
+      issue: "local state not updated with crop values after editor closes"
   missing:
-    - Trigger crop editor after upload in ImageUpload component
+    - Update local image preview state with crop values on editor close (before save)
-
+  root_cause: ""
-- truth: "Crop settings (zoom, x, y) should persist to DB and render on subsequent views"
+  debug_session: ""
-  status: failed
-  reason: "User reported: framing adjustment doesn't save, no error, no log — silent failure"
-  severity: blocker
-  test: 5
-  artifacts:
-    - src/client/routes/items/$itemId.tsx
-    - src/server/routes/items.ts
-  missing:
-    - Debug crop save pipeline (client mutation → API → DB)