Reviewed-on: https://codeberg.org/jlmakiola/calendula/pulls/102
This commit is contained in:
@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ flowchart TD
|
||||
Repo["CalendarRepository\n(interface + impl, Flow-based, io-dispatched)"]
|
||||
DS["CalendarDataSource\n(interface + AndroidCalendarDataSource)"]
|
||||
Prefs["SettingsPrefs / CalendarPrefs\n(DataStore)"]
|
||||
Rem["reminders/\nReminderAlertStore + ReminderNotifier"]
|
||||
Rem["reminders/\nReminderScanner + ReminderNotifier"]
|
||||
end
|
||||
Provider[("CalendarContract\n(system calendar provider)")]
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -137,29 +137,56 @@ can't fake a conflict.
|
||||
|
||||
## Reminder delivery
|
||||
|
||||
The provider schedules reminder alarms (for `METHOD_ALERT` rows only) and
|
||||
broadcasts `EVENT_REMINDER` — but posts no notification; a calendar app
|
||||
must (the Etar model):
|
||||
Calendula plans and fires its own reminders. It reads the offsets in
|
||||
`Reminders` as data, works out when each occurrence's reminder is due, and holds
|
||||
**one** exact alarm for the earliest one still ahead:
|
||||
|
||||
```mermaid
|
||||
sequenceDiagram
|
||||
participant P as CalendarProvider
|
||||
participant R as EventReminderReceiver
|
||||
participant S as ReminderAlertStore
|
||||
participant T as Trigger (alarm / boot / time change / edit / launch / daily worker)
|
||||
participant Sc as ReminderScanner
|
||||
participant Src as ReminderInstanceSource
|
||||
participant P as ReminderPlan (pure)
|
||||
participant N as ReminderNotifier
|
||||
P->>R: EVENT_REMINDER broadcast (manifest receiver, exported)
|
||||
R->>S: dueAlerts(now) — CalendarAlerts: SCHEDULED, alarmTime ≤ now
|
||||
S-->>R: due alerts
|
||||
R->>N: post(alert) — one notification per alert, tag = alert id
|
||||
R->>S: markFired(ids) — best effort, needs WRITE_CALENDAR
|
||||
participant A as ReminderAlarmScheduler
|
||||
T->>Sc: scan()
|
||||
Sc->>Src: occurrences(window) + reminderMinutes(ids)
|
||||
Src-->>Sc: Instances ⋈ Reminders
|
||||
Sc->>P: planReminders / scheduleReminders(watermark, now)
|
||||
P-->>Sc: due + next alarm
|
||||
Sc->>N: post(alert) — tag = reminder key
|
||||
Sc->>A: scheduleScan(next)
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Posting happens before marking: a crash in between re-posts silently (same
|
||||
tag + `setOnlyAlertOnce`) rather than losing a reminder. Swiped
|
||||
notifications never return because `FIRED` rows are never re-queried.
|
||||
**Why not the provider's broadcast.** It used to schedule the alarms, write the
|
||||
`CalendarAlerts` rows and broadcast `EVENT_REMINDER`, and the app only reacted.
|
||||
That chain holds on stock Android and demonstrably not everywhere: AOSP's own
|
||||
unbundled calendar carries three separate workarounds for OEM providers that
|
||||
retarget the broadcast or only write the alert row at alert time. A reacting app
|
||||
cannot tell "nothing was due" from "the broadcast never came" (#75) — and the
|
||||
reporter's silent events were in a calendar Calendula created itself, so
|
||||
`VISIBLE` was never the cause there.
|
||||
|
||||
**One visibility model.** The provider only schedules alarms for calendars with
|
||||
`Calendars.VISIBLE = 1`, so that flag *is* the app's on/off switch: Settings →
|
||||
**The watermark replaces `CalendarAlerts.STATE`.** A scan posts the reminders
|
||||
whose moment falls in `(lastScan, now]`, then moves the mark
|
||||
(`ReminderStatePrefs`). Half-open, so a scan that runs twice cannot post twice,
|
||||
while a scan that runs *late* still posts what the missed alarm owed — a reboot,
|
||||
an app update or a doze window costs nothing. A first-ever scan claims the
|
||||
present rather than the epoch, and a watermark left in the future by a clock
|
||||
change is clamped. Every trigger runs the same idempotent `scan()`, so there is
|
||||
no ordering between them to get wrong; `BOOT_COMPLETED` and `MY_PACKAGE_REPLACED`
|
||||
matter because both wipe pending alarms.
|
||||
|
||||
**All-day reminders fire at the hour the setting names.** The stored offset is
|
||||
not a plain lead time — `AllDayReminderEncoding` folds a wall-clock hour into it,
|
||||
sampled against one date's UTC offset — so taking it at face value drifts by the
|
||||
offset delta across a DST boundary, and rows from other apps carry no hour at
|
||||
all. The offset is therefore read only for *which day* it means; the hour comes
|
||||
from the global all-day reminder setting, recomposed against each occurrence's
|
||||
own date. Timed reminders need none of this: `begin` is an absolute instant.
|
||||
|
||||
**One visibility model.** The scan only plans occurrences of calendars with
|
||||
`Calendars.VISIBLE = 1`, and that flag *is* the app's on/off switch: Settings →
|
||||
Calendars writes it (one calendar per update — `CalendarProvider2` skips its own
|
||||
`checkNextAlarm()` reschedule for any selection that isn't `_id=`), and every
|
||||
display predicate reads `CalendarSource.isVisibleInSystem`. The reconciliation
|
||||
@@ -171,16 +198,14 @@ the app has not been allowed to write yet (read-only permission grant, or a
|
||||
pre-permission launch); `CalendarVisibilityReconciler` drains it entry by entry,
|
||||
and until it does, the repository and `ReminderNotifier.post` honour it. That
|
||||
gate also covers a snooze re-shown from our own alarm after its calendar was
|
||||
switched off. Silencing is not handling: an alert the gate drops keeps its
|
||||
`SCHEDULED` state while its event is still ahead (`handledAlertIds`), so
|
||||
switching the calendar back on re-posts it (`ReminderRecovery`) instead of
|
||||
losing it — the provider's own table is the stash. The drawer's filter sheet
|
||||
(`CalendarPrefs.hiddenCalendarIds`) is a separate in-app declutter that never
|
||||
touches reminders.
|
||||
switched off. The drawer's filter sheet (`CalendarPrefs.hiddenCalendarIds`) is a
|
||||
separate in-app declutter that never touches reminders.
|
||||
|
||||
Deliberately absent until real devices prove it necessary: own alarm
|
||||
scheduling, `BOOT_COMPLETED`, snooze/dismiss actions, battery-exemption
|
||||
prompts.
|
||||
Deliberately absent: a fallback to the provider's `EVENT_REMINDER` broadcast.
|
||||
Keeping both would double-post wherever the provider works, and Etar's way out —
|
||||
a latch that disables its own scheduling once a real broadcast arrives — cannot
|
||||
be copied, because our failure mode includes a broadcast that arrives with no
|
||||
alert row behind it.
|
||||
|
||||
## Testing
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user