Jean-Luc Makiola
0ea79e0853
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
10 KiB
phase, verified, status, score, re_verification
| phase | verified | status | score | re_verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07-task-sorting | 2026-03-16T22:00:00Z | passed | 9/9 must-haves verified | false |
Phase 7: Task Sorting Verification Report
Phase Goal: Users can reorder task lists by the dimension most useful to them — name, how often the task recurs, or how much effort it requires Verified: 2026-03-16T22:00:00Z Status: passed Re-verification: No — initial verification
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sort preference persists across app restarts | VERIFIED | SortPreferenceNotifier._loadPersisted() reads SharedPreferences.getString('task_sort_option') on build; 2 restart-recovery tests pass |
| 2 | CalendarDayList tasks are sorted according to the active sort preference | VERIFIED | calendarDayProvider calls ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider) and applies _sortTasks(dayTasks, sortOption) before returning CalendarDayState |
| 3 | TaskListScreen tasks are sorted according to the active sort preference | VERIFIED | tasksInRoomProvider calls ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider) and applies stream.map((tasks) => _sortTasksRaw(tasks, sortOption)) |
| 4 | Default sort is alphabetical (matches current CalendarDayList behavior) | VERIFIED | SortPreferenceNotifier.build() returns TaskSortOption.alphabetical synchronously; test "build() returns default state of alphabetical" confirms |
| 5 | A sort dropdown is visible in the HomeScreen AppBar showing the current label | VERIFIED | HomeScreen.build() returns Scaffold(appBar: AppBar(actions: const [SortDropdown()])) — wired and rendered |
| 6 | A sort dropdown is visible in the TaskListScreen AppBar | VERIFIED | TaskListScreen.build() AppBar actions list: [const SortDropdown(), edit IconButton, delete IconButton] |
| 7 | Tapping the dropdown shows three options: A-Z, Intervall, Aufwand | VERIFIED | SortDropdown builds PopupMenuButton from TaskSortOption.values (3 items), labels map to l10n.sortAlphabetical/sortInterval/sortEffort |
| 8 | Selecting a sort option updates the task list order immediately | VERIFIED | onSelected calls ref.read(sortPreferenceProvider.notifier).setSortOption(value); providers watch sortPreferenceProvider and rebuild reactively |
| 9 | The sort preference persists across screen navigations and app restarts | VERIFIED | @Riverpod(keepAlive: true) prevents disposal during navigation; SharedPreferences stores and reloads value |
Score: 9/9 truths verified
Required Artifacts
Plan 07-01 Artifacts
| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
lib/features/tasks/domain/task_sort_option.dart |
TaskSortOption enum with alphabetical, interval, effort |
VERIFIED | Exactly 3 values, comments match intent. No stubs. |
lib/features/tasks/presentation/sort_preference_notifier.dart |
SortPreferenceNotifier with SharedPreferences persistence |
VERIFIED | build() returns alphabetical synchronously, _loadPersisted() async, setSortOption() sets state + persists. Pattern matches ThemeNotifier. |
lib/features/tasks/presentation/sort_preference_notifier.g.dart |
Generated Riverpod provider file | VERIFIED | Generated correctly; sortPreferenceProvider declared as SortPreferenceNotifierProvider._() with isAutoDispose: false (keepAlive). |
lib/features/home/presentation/calendar_providers.dart |
calendarDayProvider sorts dayTasks by active sort preference |
VERIFIED | ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider) present. _sortTasks() helper implements all 3 sort modes. overdueTasks intentionally unsorted. |
lib/features/tasks/presentation/task_providers.dart |
tasksInRoomProvider sorts tasks by active sort preference |
VERIFIED | ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider) present. _sortTasksRaw() helper + stream.map() applied correctly. |
test/features/tasks/presentation/sort_preference_notifier_test.dart |
Unit tests for sort preference persistence and default | VERIFIED | 7 tests: default alphabetical, setSortOption interval, setSortOption effort, persist to SharedPreferences, restart recovery (effort), restart recovery (interval), unknown value fallback. |
Plan 07-02 Artifacts
| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
lib/features/tasks/presentation/sort_dropdown.dart |
Reusable SortDropdown ConsumerWidget |
VERIFIED | ConsumerWidget, PopupMenuButton<TaskSortOption>, Opacity check mark pattern, ref.watch for display, ref.read for mutation, _label() helper. |
lib/features/home/presentation/home_screen.dart |
HomeScreen with AppBar containing SortDropdown |
VERIFIED | Scaffold(appBar: AppBar(title: Text(l10n.tabHome), actions: const [SortDropdown()])). Existing Stack body preserved. |
lib/features/tasks/presentation/task_list_screen.dart |
TaskListScreen AppBar with SortDropdown before edit/delete |
VERIFIED | actions: [const SortDropdown(), IconButton(edit), IconButton(delete)]. Correct order. |
Key Link Verification
Plan 07-01 Key Links
| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
calendar_providers.dart |
sortPreferenceProvider |
ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider) in calendarDayProvider |
WIRED | Line 77: final sortOption = ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider);. Applied at line 101: dayTasks: _sortTasks(dayTasks, sortOption). |
task_providers.dart |
sortPreferenceProvider |
ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider) in tasksInRoomProvider |
WIRED | Line 43: final sortOption = ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider);. Applied at lines 44-46 via stream.map. |
Plan 07-02 Key Links
| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
sort_dropdown.dart |
sortPreferenceProvider |
ref.watch for display, ref.read for mutation |
WIRED | Line 21: ref.watch(sortPreferenceProvider). Line 27: ref.read(sortPreferenceProvider.notifier).setSortOption(value). |
home_screen.dart |
sort_dropdown.dart |
SortDropdown widget in AppBar actions |
WIRED | Import on line 7. Used in AppBar(actions: const [SortDropdown()]) on line 37. |
task_list_screen.dart |
sort_dropdown.dart |
SortDropdown widget in AppBar actions |
WIRED | Import on line 7. Used in actions: [const SortDropdown(), ...] on line 31. |
Requirements Coverage
| Requirement | Source Plan | Description | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SORT-01 | 07-01, 07-02 | User can sort tasks alphabetically | SATISFIED | TaskSortOption.alphabetical is the default. _sortTasks() and _sortTasksRaw() implement case-insensitive A-Z sort. SortDropdown displays "A–Z" label (l10n). |
| SORT-02 | 07-01, 07-02 | User can sort tasks by frequency interval | SATISFIED | TaskSortOption.interval sort implemented: intervalType.index ascending with intervalDays tiebreaker. Displayed as "Intervall" in SortDropdown. |
| SORT-03 | 07-01, 07-02 | User can sort tasks by effort level | SATISFIED | TaskSortOption.effort sort implemented: effortLevel.index ascending (low=0, medium=1, high=2). Displayed as "Aufwand" in SortDropdown. |
No orphaned requirements. All three SORT requirements are claimed by both plans and fully implemented.
Anti-Patterns Found
None. All seven implementation files scanned — no TODO, FIXME, XXX, HACK, PLACEHOLDER, return null, return {}, return [], or empty arrow functions found.
Human Verification Required
1. Visual check: Sort dropdown appearance in AppBar
Test: Launch the app, navigate to HomeScreen. Verify the AppBar shows a sort icon (Icons.sort) followed by the current sort label text "A–Z". Expected: Sort icon and "A–Z" text visible in the top-right AppBar area. Why human: Widget rendering and visual layout cannot be verified programmatically.
2. Popup menu interaction: Check marks on active option
Test: Tap the sort dropdown, verify three items appear with a check mark next to the currently selected option and no check mark on the other two. Expected: Check mark visible on "A–Z" (default), invisible (but space-preserving) on "Intervall" and "Aufwand". Why human: Opacity(0) vs Opacity(1) rendering and visual alignment cannot be verified with grep.
3. Reactive reorder on selection
Test: With tasks loaded in HomeScreen, tap the sort dropdown and select "Aufwand". Verify the task list reorders immediately without a page reload. Expected: Task list updates instantly, sorted low-effort first. Why human: Real-time Riverpod reactive rebuild requires a running app to observe.
4. Cross-screen persistence of sort preference
Test: Select "Intervall" in HomeScreen, then navigate to a room's TaskListScreen. Verify the sort dropdown there also shows "Intervall".
Expected: Sort preference is shared across screens (same sortPreferenceProvider, keepAlive: true).
Why human: Cross-screen navigation state cannot be verified statically.
Gaps Summary
None. All 9 observable truths verified. All artifacts exist, are substantive, and are correctly wired. All 3 requirements (SORT-01, SORT-02, SORT-03) are fully satisfied. All 5 commits (a9f2983, 13c7d62, 3697e4e, e5eccb7, a3e4d02) confirmed present in git log. No anti-patterns detected in implementation files.
The phase delivers its stated goal: users can reorder task lists by name (A–Z), frequency interval, or effort level via a persistent, reactive sort preference accessible from both HomeScreen and TaskListScreen AppBars.
Verified: 2026-03-16T22:00:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)