12 KiB
phase, verified, status, score, human_verification
| phase | verified | status | score | human_verification | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 09-task-creation-ux | 2026-03-18T23:00:00Z | human_needed | 8/8 must-haves verified |
|
Phase 9: Task Creation UX Verification Report
Phase Goal: Users can set any recurring frequency intuitively without hunting through a grid of preset chips — common frequencies are one tap away, custom intervals are freeform Verified: 2026-03-18T23:00:00Z Status: human_needed Re-verification: No — initial verification
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Frequency section shows 4 shortcut chips (Taeglich, Woechentlich, Alle 2 Wochen, Monatlich) above the freeform picker | VERIFIED | _buildFrequencySelector() at line 234 iterates _ShortcutFrequency.values in a Wrap with ChoiceChip for each of the 4 values; _buildFrequencyPickerRow() is called unconditionally below the Wrap |
| 2 | The freeform 'Every [N] [unit]' picker row is always visible — not hidden behind a Custom toggle | VERIFIED | _buildFrequencyPickerRow(l10n, theme) is called unconditionally at line 262 with no conditional wrapping; _isCustomFrequency field removed entirely |
| 3 | Tapping a shortcut chip highlights it AND populates the picker with the corresponding values | VERIFIED | onSelected at line 247 calls shortcut.toPickerValues() and setState setting both _activeShortcut = shortcut and updating _customIntervalController.text + _customUnit; selected: _activeShortcut == shortcut drives the highlight |
| 4 | Editing the picker number or unit manually deselects any highlighted chip | VERIFIED | onChanged in TextFormField at line 298 calls _ShortcutFrequency.fromPickerValues(...) — returns null for non-matching values, clearing _activeShortcut; SegmentedButton.onSelectionChanged at line 326 does the same |
| 5 | Any arbitrary interval (e.g., every 5 days, every 3 weeks, every 2 months) can be entered directly in the freeform picker | VERIFIED | Picker is a TextFormField with FilteringTextInputFormatter.digitsOnly (no max) and a 3-segment unit selector; _resolveFrequency() at line 393 maps all day/week/month combinations to the correct IntervalType values without requiring any mode switch |
| 6 | Editing an existing daily task shows 'Taeglich' chip highlighted and picker showing 1/Tage | VERIFIED | _loadExistingTask() at line 56: case IntervalType.daily sets _customUnit = _CustomUnit.days and _customIntervalController.text = '1'; then _ShortcutFrequency.fromPickerValues(1, days) returns daily — highlighting the chip |
| 7 | Editing an existing quarterly task (3 months) shows no chip highlighted and picker showing 3/Monate | VERIFIED | case IntervalType.quarterly sets _customUnit = _CustomUnit.months and _customIntervalController.text = '3'; fromPickerValues(3, months) returns null (3 months is not a shortcut), leaving _activeShortcut null |
| 8 | Saving a task from the new picker produces the correct IntervalType and intervalDays values | VERIFIED | _resolveFrequency() maps: 1 day → (daily, 1); N days → (everyNDays, N); 1 week → (weekly, 1); 2 weeks → (biweekly, 14); N weeks (N>2) → (everyNDays, N*7); 1 month → (monthly, 1, anchorDay); N months → (everyNMonths, N, anchorDay). Result is applied in _onSave() at line 423. All 144 existing tests pass. |
Score: 8/8 truths verified (automated)
Required Artifacts
| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
lib/features/tasks/presentation/task_form_screen.dart |
Reworked frequency picker with shortcut chips + freeform picker | VERIFIED | File exists, 536 lines; contains _ShortcutFrequency enum (line 504), _activeShortcut state (line 37), _buildFrequencySelector() (line 234), _buildFrequencyPickerRow() (line 280), _resolveFrequency() (line 393), _loadExistingTask() (line 56) |
lib/l10n/app_de.arb |
German l10n strings for shortcut chip labels | VERIFIED | Contains frequencyShortcutDaily ("Täglich"), frequencyShortcutWeekly ("Wöchentlich"), frequencyShortcutBiweekly ("Alle 2 Wochen"), frequencyShortcutMonthly ("Monatlich") at lines 51-54 |
lib/l10n/app_localizations.dart |
Abstract getters for new shortcut strings | VERIFIED | frequencyShortcutDaily, frequencyShortcutWeekly, frequencyShortcutBiweekly, frequencyShortcutMonthly abstract getters present at lines 325-347 |
lib/l10n/app_localizations_de.dart |
German implementations of shortcut string getters | VERIFIED | All 4 @override getter implementations present at lines 132-141 with correct German strings |
Key Link Verification
| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
task_form_screen.dart |
lib/features/tasks/domain/frequency.dart |
IntervalType enum in _resolveFrequency() and _loadExistingTask() |
WIRED | IntervalType. referenced at 13 sites (lines 71, 74, 83, 86, 89, 92, 95, 98, 398, 400, 403, 406, 408, 411, 413); all 8 enum values handled; frequency.dart imported via ../domain/frequency.dart |
task_form_screen.dart |
lib/l10n/app_de.arb |
AppLocalizations for chip labels via l10n.frequencyShortcut* |
WIRED | l10n.frequencyShortcutDaily/Weekly/Biweekly/Monthly called at lines 270-276 in _shortcutLabel(); AppLocalizations imported at line 10 |
Requirements Coverage
| Requirement | Source Plan | Description | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TCX-01 | 09-01-PLAN.md | Frequency picker presents an intuitive "Every [N] [unit]" interface instead of a flat grid of preset chips | SATISFIED | _buildFrequencyPickerRow() always-visible TextFormField + SegmentedButton row replaces the old 10-chip FrequencyInterval.presets grid; _isCustomFrequency and _selectedPreset removed entirely |
| TCX-02 | 09-01-PLAN.md | Common frequencies (daily, weekly, biweekly, monthly) are available as quick-select shortcuts without scrolling through all options | SATISFIED | _ShortcutFrequency.values iterated in a Wrap at lines 243-257; 4 ChoiceChips one-tap select and populate the picker |
| TCX-03 | 09-01-PLAN.md | User can set any arbitrary interval without needing to select "Custom" first | SATISFIED | Picker is always visible; number field accepts any positive integer; no mode gate or "Custom" toggle exists in the code |
| TCX-04 | 09-01-PLAN.md | The frequency picker preserves all existing interval types and scheduling behavior (calendar-anchored monthly/quarterly/yearly with anchor memory) | SATISFIED | _resolveFrequency() passes anchorDay: _dueDate.day for monthly and everyNMonths; _loadExistingTask() handles all 8 IntervalType values in a complete exhaustive switch; frequency.dart not modified; 144 tests pass |
No orphaned requirements found — all 4 TCX-* IDs declared in PLAN frontmatter are present in REQUIREMENTS.md and verified above.
Anti-Patterns Found
| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None | — | — | — | — |
No TODOs, FIXMEs, placeholders, empty implementations, or console.log-only handlers found in any modified file.
Removed code confirmed absent:
_selectedPresetfield: not found_isCustomFrequencyfield: not foundFrequencyInterval.presetsiteration loop: not found_buildCustomFrequencyInput(old name): not found (correctly renamed to_buildFrequencyPickerRow)
Backward compatibility confirmed:
frequency.dartis unchanged;FrequencyInterval.presetsremains in the model fortemplate_picker_sheet.dartandtask_row.dartusage
Human Verification Required
All automated checks passed. The following items require a running app to confirm the interactive UX behavior:
1. Frequency Section Layout
Test: Launch the app, navigate to any room, tap "+" to create a new task, scroll to the "Wiederholung" section. Expected: A row of 4 shortcut chips (Täglich, Wöchentlich, Alle 2 Wochen, Monatlich) appears in a compact Wrap; below them the always-visible "Alle [N] [Tage|Wochen|Monate]" picker row; "Wöchentlich" chip is highlighted by default; picker shows "1" with "Wochen" segment selected. Why human: Visual layout, spacing, and default highlight state require running the app.
2. Chip-to-Picker Bidirectional Sync
Test: Tap "Täglich" — verify chip highlights and picker updates to "1"/"Tage". Tap "Monatlich" — verify chip highlights and picker updates to "1"/"Monate". Previous chip deselects. Expected: Smooth single-tap update of both chip highlight and picker values. Why human: Widget interaction and visual state transitions require running the app.
3. Picker-to-Chip Reverse Sync
Test: With "Wöchentlich" highlighted, type "5" in the number field. Verify all chips deselect. Change unit to "Tage" — still no chip selected. Type "1" with "Tage" selected — verify "Täglich" chip auto-highlights. Expected: The picker editing recalculates chip highlight in real time. Why human: Text field onChange and SegmentedButton interaction require running the app.
4. Round-Trip Edit Mode — Shortcut Task
Test: Create a task using "Alle 2 Wochen" shortcut. Re-open it in edit mode. Expected: "Alle 2 Wochen" chip is highlighted; picker shows "2" with "Wochen" selected. Why human: Requires saving to database and reopening to test _loadExistingTask() end-to-end.
5. Round-Trip Edit Mode — Non-Shortcut Task
Test: Create a task with freeform "5"/"Tage". Re-open it in edit mode. Expected: No chip highlighted; picker shows "5" with "Tage" selected. Why human: Requires running the app and database round-trip.
6. Quarterly / Yearly Task Edit Mode
Test: If an existing quarterly or yearly task is available, open it in edit mode. Expected: Quarterly task: no chip highlighted, picker shows "3"/"Monate". Yearly task: picker shows "12"/"Monate" with no chip. Why human: Requires an existing task with IntervalType.quarterly or IntervalType.yearly in the database.
Static Analysis and Tests
flutter analyze --no-fatal-infos: No issues found (ran 2026-03-18)flutter test: 144/144 tests passed (ran 2026-03-18)- Commit
8a0b69bverified: feat(09-01) with correct 4-file diff (task_form_screen.dart +179/-115, app_de.arb +4, app_localizations.dart +24, app_localizations_de.dart +12)
Gaps Summary
No gaps found. All automated must-haves are verified. The phase goal — intuitive frequency selection with shortcut chips and always-visible freeform picker — is fully implemented in the codebase. Human verification of interactive UX behavior is the only remaining item.
Verified: 2026-03-18T23:00:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)